• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About the NY Sports Report
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Policy
    • Copyright Information
  • Staff
  • Contact
NY Sports Report

NY Sports Report

Independent Gotham Sports Coverage

Berkshire Hathaway - Joe McDonald
  • Baseball
    • New York Mets
    • New York Yankees
  • Basketball
    • New York Knicks
    • Brooklyn Nets
    • College
  • Football
    • New York Giants
    • New York Jets
  • Hockey
    • New Jersey Devils
    • New York Islanders
    • New York Rangers
  • Other Sports
  • Roundup

McDonald: Another Generational Met Gets Away

December 11, 2025 by Joe McDonald Leave a Comment

Congratulations, David Stearns. You did it.
You made me get back in the game.

For the last few years, my old Sportsday staff has been asking me to start a new site. Sportsday was gone—sold to Catena Media, and they want to use the site for their purposes.

So what is an old sports reporter to do?
Well… start a new one.

Welcome to The NY Sports Report, which is staffed by some familiar faces, and we hope you will enjoy our coverage.

That said, it also gives me an outlet to post my views on the world of New York sports.
And right now, I am angry.

The Mets liked to throw around the term “generational talent” with their pursuit of Juan Soto last year, and they were right to pay the $765 million for him over the next decade and a half.

However, they should have thought about the term “Generational Met” when it came to staffing their own team. And yesterday, in one full swoop, they let the latest Generational Met get away.

Just like they did with Tom Seaver, Darryl Strawberry, Doc Gooden, and even José Reyes.
Only David Wright stuck around—and his time was cut short due to injuries.

And now Pete Alonso goes to the Baltimore Orioles for $155 million over the next five years.

Look, I’m not going to sit here and say Alonso was perfect. He wasn’t the greatest defensive first baseman, and his baserunning was almost comical at times. But he sure could hit home runs, and he sure liked it here.

And let’s not forget—the fans liked him as well. It was a marriage made in Flushing heaven.

Now you have the Mets fanbase in open revolt, and Stearns is trying to fill this team with high-priced mercenaries, not true Mets who loved it here.

And there’s something to be said for legacy as well. If Alonso stuck around, No. 20 would probably have been retired one day. And there’s no doubt that if Pete made it into the Hall, it would have been as a Met.

Now he’s an Oriole, and if he reaches the 500-homer mark at Camden Yards, there’s a chance he goes in as a bird.

But let’s not get ahead of ourselves. The first problem is the Mets just lost 38 homers and over 120 RBIs. They need to replace that production.

A lot of times you see quick pivots. Nothing today.

Sure, it’s a long winter—but it just got colder in Met-land.
Great job, Stearns.
Cold winter and no Polar Bear.

You can see why I’m angry.

Filed Under: Featured Story, New York Mets

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

More to See

Moeller: These Knicks Can Further Cement the ’73 Knicks Legacy

June 2, 2026 By Jeff Moeller

Kate Pellegrino Named Caldwell University Head Women’s Soccer Coach

June 1, 2026 By Jerry Milani

Footer

NY Sports Report

The NY Sports Report is an independent site that covers all the major New York sports teams, owned by Sportsday Publishing, LLC. From 2004-2020, the staff ran NY Sports Day which was sold during the pandemic and then sold again a year later. In Jan 2025, the company that owned NYSD, shut it down leaving the staff looking for new outlets. In December 2025, the NY Sports Report was born. We … About Us about About the NY Sports Report

Recent

  • San Antonio Claims Championship Over New York in Seven Games in Strat-O-Matic NBA Finals Simulation
  • Moeller: These Knicks Can Further Cement the ’73 Knicks Legacy
  • Kate Pellegrino Named Caldwell University Head Women’s Soccer Coach
  • Metropolitan Oval and Soccer Stars United Launch Met Oval SSU Manhattan’s First Elite Development Program Built for the City
  • Tracy McGrady’s Big Apple Moment

Search

Tags

360 hoops Aaron Glenn Aaron Rodgers atlantic city auriemma award awards baseball basketball betty wold johnson foundation boxing brey cacc caldwell college college basketball columbia corino fairfield Giants Giants-Raiders Toilet Bowl globetrotters hofstra italian american Jaxson Dart No. 1 Draft Pick Jets John Harbaugh Jon Gruden Knicks Madison Square Garden met basketball writers met writers Naismith Basketball Hall of Fame ncaa new jersey nyu queens soccer st. john's strat-o-matic uconn wcsu westchester soccer club women's sports foundation wrestling

Copyright © 2026 · Sportsday Publishing, LLC · Log in